A medical answering service is a company that can handle the after hours or overflow calls from your office. The type of services they offer vary a lot, from basic message relay and emergency dispatching to appointment scheduling and more. To find out who’s the best, we reviewed 2 of the top medical answering services and compared their price, features and reputation. See our recommendation as well as a detailed comparison below:
Best Medical Answering Service: Call4Health
We recommend Call4Health.com because they offer the biggest range of services at the lowest price.
Best Medical Answering Service Comparison Table
Price for Basic
depending on call
Callers can “press 1” to
confirm or “press 2” to
$0.13 per reminder
that are professionally
recorded for your
$0.20 per reminder
nurses can triage
patients and provide basic medical advice
$14.50 per call
Available? (to receive
but it costs
but it costs
$135 one-time fee
How Medical Answering Services Work:
First, a quick note on what medical answering services actually offer. It’s typical for an answering provider to have many different types of services within their plans. Clients can add and subtract features as they go. In particular, we’ve noticed 3 main tiers of service, starting with the simplest (and most affordable) and moving up to the advanced (and most expensive):
- Basic Messaging. A receptionist takes the call, copies the message and sends it to you via email or text. If it’s an emergency, you or your on-call provider may receive a phone call or alert instead.
- Appointment Scheduling. Accessing your calendar, receptionists schedule patients for you. Usually they can also verify insurance and process credits over the phone. This type of service also includes appointment reminders.
- Nurse Triage. Patients can speak with a registered nurse and receive basic medical direction. This is ideal for physicians who want to give their patients 24/7 access to care, yet still sleep at night.
Why We Recommend Call4Health as the Best Medical Answering Service
Call4Health offers all 3 tiers of service at prices that beat their competitors. For as little as around $300/month, you could set up a full answering service, including basic messaging – in which a receptionist takes messages from callers and forwards them to you as a text or email, emergency dispatching – in which receptionists alert you or your on-call provider in the event of an emergency, appointment scheduling and appointment reminders. The equivalent service from Stericycle Communications would cost around $2,000/month.
Of all the services we reviewed, Call4Health is the only one to offer nurse triage, where a registered nurse can advise your patients after hours. What’s also nice about Call4Health is how you can pick and choose features to personalize your service. For example, if you prefer to handle appointment scheduling yourself, you could just use Call4Health just for appointment reminders and vice versa.
Pricing varies based on the different features you want and the number of minutes you need (i.e. call volume) per month. Basic messaging costs $153/month for 150 minutes after taxes and fees. 150 minutes usually translates to around 100 calls.
There’s also a $20 fee if you want to accept calls on a holiday. Call4Health counts 8 holidays throughout the year, including New Years Day, Labor Day, Memorial Day and the 4th of July.
Call4Health also has an appointment scheduling service that charges separately. It’s about $131/month for 150 minutes. Appointment reminders, which can be added with appointment scheduling or separately, are charged at $0.13 per call. Just note that you may need more minutes for scheduling than basic messaging, since things like scheduling and copying credit card information can take longer. Finally, Call4Health’s nurse triage starts at $145 for 10 calls. It’s priced at $14.50 per call, but you have to sign up for a minimum of 10 calls.
Like Call4Health, there’s different packages available and pricing varies based on call volume, as well as the number of physicians and locations of your medical practice. Basic messaging for 1 doctor at 1 location costs $178.87/month for 150 minutes. If you want appointment scheduling and reminders, the cost shoots up to around $2,000/month, which is far more expensive than Call4Health’s charge of $150-$300/month.
Appointment reminders cost 20 cents each. Stericycle does not offer nurse triage.
Aside from basic dispatching, each service offers a few unique feature. Call4Health offers nurse triage over the phone as an add-on service, whereas Stericycle agents can provide insurance verification.
Call4Health offers the full range of answering services, including basic message relay, emergency dispatching, appointment scheduling, appointment reminders and nurse triage. Appointment reminders are unique in that callers will hear an automated message and be able to press 1 to confirm or press 2 to cancel their appointment. If they cancel, you have the option of forwarding that caller to a receptionist to reschedule the appointment.
Nurse triage is another feature unique to Call4Health. Patients can speak with a registered nurse and receive basic medical direction, such as whether or not to go to the emergency room and/or what measures they can take at home before getting in touch with their doctor the next day.
Like Call4Health, Stericycle offers the full range of services minus nurse triage. They also do a few things Call4Health does not typically do, such as process and verify insurance information over the phone. This is ideal if you have a lot of first time patients. Call4Health also records personalized messages for appointment reminders and offers call recording. While these advanced features partly explain the higher price tag ($2,000/month), it’s questionable whether or not they justify it. Call4Health has most of the same features for only around $300/month.
Because HIPAA regulations can prohibit physicians from receiving patient messages via normal SMS text, both of these services offer a secure mobile app for messaging.
Call4Health has a basic mobile app for receiving messages. As with the other apps, it adds extra security measures to comply with HIPAA standards of patient confidentiality. The cost for the mobile app is $6/month.
There’s not too much in the way of user reviews for these services, however we were able to gauge their reputation by reading employee reviews on Indeed and and reading customer reviews on the app store. From what we heard, both appear to be reliable and professional services.
Call4Health has mostly positive reviews on Indeed. Many employees note the higher level of responsibility they get compared to a regular call center job and the specialized medical knowledge they receive. Still, it doesn’t seem immune from the typical call center grind, such as the high call volumes and repetitive work.
The Bottom Line
For doctors and medical professionals, it’s important to choose an answering service that specializes in the medical industry. Not only are you more likely to find the set of services you need, like appointment confirmations and emergency dispatching, but you can be assured receptionists are familiar with medical terminology and trained to handle the sensitive needs of patients. Also, you’ll find HIPAA compliant solutions for receiving text messages and communicating with patients, which you probably won’t find from a generic answering service.
As for who’s the best medical answering service, Call4Health is the clear winner. They offer just about all the same features as Stericycle, plus more (nurse triage) and have a similarly positive reputation. Yet, their service costs a fraction of the price: almost 1/6th as much.