50 Best Franchises & 50 Worst Franchises by SBA Default Rates

Over 100,000 franchises are started in the United States annually. However, not all franchises are created equally. Using loan data obtained directly from the Small Business Administration (SBA) for 2000 – 2018, we evaluated the 50 best franchises based on SBA loan repayment rates and the 50 worst franchises based on SBA loan default rates.

The 50 best franchises saw default rates ranging from 8% to 25% on SBA loans, while the 50 worst franchises had default rates ranging from 52% to 98% on their SBA loans. SBA loan default rates should not be the only metric that you use when deciding which franchise to invest in, however.

While SBA loans are a common method of financing a franchise, they are typically used by borrowers who were unable to obtain traditional financing. SBA loan rates are competitive, and qualification requirements are often less stringent than traditional financing. SBA default rates do not include any franchises that were funded via traditional financing or cash deals, and only represent part of the overall picture of a franchise’s potential for success.

50 Best Franchises by SBA Default Rates

Rank	Franchise Name	SBA Loan Default Rate	# of SBA 7a Loans from 2000-2018 (excluding currently outstanding loans)	Loans Charged-Off or Canceled
1	Comfort Keepers	8.00%	25	2
2	Christian Brothers Automotive	8.20%	61	5
3	Home Instead Senior Care	9.09%	44	4
4	Once Upon A Child	11.90%	42	5
5	Zeppe's	12.00%	25	3
6	Comfort Inn	12.50%	72	9
7	Buffalo Wild Wings(FKA BW-3)	13.51%	37	5
8	Plato's Closet	13.79%	58	8
9	Merlin's Muffler	13.79%	29	4
10	H & R Block	13.89%	36	5
11	Sports Clips	14.09%	291	41
12	Culver's Frozen Custard	14.56%	103	15
13	Molly Maid	15.25%	59	9
14	Five Guys Famous Burgers And Fries	15.38%	26	4
15	Penn Station, Inc.	16.00%	25	4
16	Cookies By Design	16.28%	43	7
17	Papa Murphy's Take & Bake Pizza	16.67%	192	32
18	Medicap Pharmacy	16.67%	54	9
19	Great Clips	17.16%	204	35
20	Jackson Hewitt Tax Service	17.24%	58	10
21	The Cleaning Authority	17.24%	29	5
22	Primrose School	17.56%	131	23
23	Kids R Kids	17.65%	68	12
24	Wild Birds Unlimited	17.65%	34	6
25	Signs By Tomorrow	18.75%	48	9
26	Napa Auto Parts	19.61%	51	10
27	Massage Envy	19.80%	197	39
28	Pinch-a-Penny	20.00%	25	5
29	Jimmy John's	20.23%	173	35
30	Subway Sandwich Shop	20.49%	2791	572
31	Hampton Inns	20.69%	29	6
32	Liberty Tax Service	20.91%	110	23
33	Taco Bell	21.21%	33	7
34	Aussie Pet Mobile Villa Park	21.43%	28	6
35	Little Caesar's Pizza	21.57%	153	33
36	Wingstop Restaurant	22.17%	230	51
37	Servpro	22.39%	201	45
38	Jani-King	22.58%	31	7
39	UPS Store	22.92%	301	69
40	Money Mailer	23.08%	26	6
41	Line-X	23.47%	98	23
42	ServiceMaster	23.60%	89	21
43	Goddard Early Learning Center	23.78%	143	34
44	Maid Brigade	24.00%	25	6
45	Crown Trophy	24.00%	25	6
46	CertaPro Painters	24.10%	83	20
47	Postal Connections Of America	24.14%	29	7
48	Mail Boxes Etc.	24.17%	720	174
49	Lawn Doctor	24.24%	33	8
50	Zaxby's	25.00%	60	15

How the Best Franchises Compare

For all of the franchises with the best SBA loan repayment rates, more than three-quarters of their SBA loans were paid in full from 2000 to 2018. This indicates that these franchises performed well enough that their owners were able to meet all their obligations. At number one on the list, Comfort Keepers, an in-home care provider for seniors, had a 92% SBA 7(a) loan success rate, with only two of the 25 loans made defaulting during this period.

The 50 franchises with the best SBA loan repayment rates are from all different industries, but many are restaurant franchises like Subway, Jimmy John’s, Buffalo Wild Wings, and Little Caesars Pizza. Subway in particular was impressive. Even though Subway franchisees together took out more than 2,700 SBA loans from 2000 through 2018, 80% of the loans were paid back in full. Barber shops (e.g., Sports Clips, Great Clips) and cleaning services (e.g., Molly Maid, Merry Maids) also performed relatively well.

50 Worst Franchises by SBA Default Rates

Rank	Franchise Name	Sba Loan Default Rate	# Of Sba 7a Loans From 2000-2018 (Excluding Currently Outstanding Loans)	# Loans Charged-off Or Canceled
1	Noble Roman Pizza	92.31%	26	24
2	Image Sun	80.49%	41	33
3	24 Seven Vending	79.49%	39	31
4	Wireless Toyz	73.81%	42	31
5	Executive Tans	72.00%	50	36
6	Play N Trade	71.43%	49	35
7	Country Clutter	71.43%	28	20
8	Camille's Sidewalk Café	69.64%	56	39
9	Pro Golf	66.67%	36	24
10	Figaro's Italian Pizza	66.67%	36	24
11	Buffalo Wings & Rings	66.67%	33	22
12	Planet Beach	63.28%	305	193
13	Obee's Soup Salad Subs	63.04%	46	29
14	Pita Pit	62.86%	35	22
15	Amoco	61.76%	34	21
16	Athlete's Foot	61.54%	39	24
17	Mr. Transmission	61.54%	26	16
18	Beef O'Brady's	61.17%	103	63
19	Golf Etc.	61.11%	108	66
20	Bounceu	61.11%	36	22
21	Dream Dinners	60.53%	76	46
22	Atlanta Bread Company	60.44%	91	55
23	Petland	59.81%	107	64
24	Salad Works, Inc.	59.70%	67	40
25	Golf U.S.A.	59.18%	49	29
26	Nick-n-Willy's Pizza	57.50%	40	23
27	Wing Zone	57.45%	47	27
28	Kwik-Kopy	57.14%	28	16
29	Philly Connection	56.96%	79	45
30	Premier Rental Purchase	56.82%	44	25
31	Econo Lube N Tune	56.52%	46	26
32	Dollar Discount Stores	56.41%	39	22
33	Steak Escape	56.00%	25	14
34	Carvel Ice Cream	55.43%	92	51
35	Coffee Beanery	54.55%	33	18
36	Taco Del Mar	54.22%	83	45
37	Dickey's Barbeque	53.85%	52	28
38	Juice It Up	53.62%	69	37
39	Great Wraps	53.57%	28	15
40	Wings To Go	53.33%	45	24
41	Lady Of America	53.33%	45	24
42	Winestyles, Inc.	53.33%	30	16
43	Wow Cafe And Wingery	53.33%	30	16
44	Red Brick Pizza	53.19%	47	25
45	Instant Imprints	53.19%	47	25
46	Submarina Sandwiches	53.13%	32	17
47	Aamco Transmissions	52.40%	208	109
48	My Gym	52.31%	65	34
49	Philly Soft Pretzel Factory	52.08%	48	25
50	King Bear Auto Service	52.00%	25	13

How the Worst Franchises by SBA Default Rate Compare

The 50 lowest performing franchises from 2000 to 2018 had SBA loan failure rates that were higher than their SBA loan success rates. In other words, more franchisees defaulted on their SBA loans than were able to pay them back successfully. For some of the worst offenders, more than three-quarters of franchisees who borrowed SBA loans defaulted on those loans.

Like those franchises with the best SBA loan repayment rates, the franchises with the highest SBA loan default rates span many industries and include fitness franchises, restaurants, and hotels. This goes to show that the particular industry of a franchise doesn’t necessarily determine success or failure.

How We Ranked the Worst & Best Franchises

We compiled the 50 best and 50 worst franchises according to their SBA loan default rates. These rankings were determined using data that we obtained from the SBA on 7(a) loans made to franchises from 2000 through 2018. SBA 7(a) loans are the most popular of the different types of SBA loans that are guaranteed by the Small Business Administration, with roughly 8.2% of 7(a) loans going to franchises.

At any given time, that status of an SBA 7(a) loan will be one of four things:

Paid-in-Full: The borrower paid off the loan on time and in full.
Charged-Off: The borrower became delinquent on the loan, and the lender took a loss.
Canceled: The borrower settled the debt with the lender for a lower amount than owed. This is also a loss for the lender.
Current: The loan is currently outstanding.

To calculate SBA loan repayment success rates, we divided the number of paid-in-full loans for each franchise by the total number of loans for the franchise (not including currently outstanding loans). We then subtracted that figure from 100% to determine the default rate, which is represented in the list of 50 best franchises.

To calculate the SBA loan default rates, we divided the number of Charged-Off and Canceled loans for each franchise by the total number of loans for the franchise (not including currently outstanding loans). We didn’t include loans currently outstanding because, even if the borrower is current now, that could change in the future. These values were then used to rank the 50 franchises with the highest SBA loan default rates.

Note: We only considered franchises that had at least 25 SBA loans originated from 2000 to 2018, as we deemed anything less than that number to likely not be statistically significant.

How to Increase Your Franchise’s Chances of Success

According to a report by Service Employees International Union, the failure rate of franchises has been increasing over time. Between 1991 and 1995, 12.7% of all franchises failed. Between 2006 and 2010, that shot up to 19.3%.

There could be several reasons for this trend. Franchise agreements, particularly for larger brands, have become more restrictive over time, giving small business owners less authority and freedom to experiment. In addition, since the recession hit in 2008, it’s been harder for small businesses, including franchises, to get capital to grow.

Whether you choose to start one of the best franchises, or any other franchise, here are four things you can do to increase your franchise’s likelihood of success:

1. Ask the franchisor for the Franchisor Disclosure Document

The Franchisor Disclosure Document (FDD) outlines the estimated costs involved in owning and running the franchise. The franchisor is legally required to provide you with it before you pay them any money. It can help you ensure that you have the capital you need to be successful. Sometimes, franchisors also include earnings estimates in their FDDs, which can help you evaluate the franchise.

2. Consider your experience

Ideally, you should have some experience to help you successfully run the franchise. For example, if you’re starting a McDonald’s franchise, do you have a background in the food service or restaurant industries? Do you have general business management experience in hiring employees, training employees, and marketing? Starting a franchise without any experience can put you at a disadvantage when challenges arise.

3. Evaluate the physical location

Location can make or break your franchise. A Subway located in downtown San Francisco is probably much costlier to operate than a Subway located in rural Pennsylvania. However, the San Francisco Subway likely gets many more customers than the Pennsylvania Subway, which helps offset the cost. This is a trade-off that you’ll have to carefully consider.

4. Secure your financing & working capital

As the repayment and default rates above suggest, investing in a franchise is no sure bet. As with any small business, you must be sufficiently capitalized. Delays in construction of your location, slow growth of a customer base, unexpected competition, lawsuits, or unrelated personal matters could all contribute to a franchisee defaulting on an SBA loan. An undercapitalized franchisee is as more at risk than others when adversity arises.

Ultimately, the key is to thoroughly research the franchise and everything that will be required of you as the owner. Doing your homework ahead of time can prevent unpleasant surprises later and put you on the path to successful franchise ownership.

Additional Resources on Starting a Franchise

Franchise opportunities abound, and owning a franchise can be a lucrative path to entrepreneurship. Just make sure to get as much financial information about a franchise as you can before buying. Our lists above of the 50 best franchises according to SBA loan repayment rates and 50 worst franchises by SBA loan default rates should give you additional insights.

Of course, you should consider more than SBA loan data when choosing which franchise to own. Lots of other factors, such as startup costs, royalty fees, number of employees you have to manage, and popularity of the franchise among customers, also come into play.

If you’re looking for more specific information, click on the links below:

Once you choose which franchise you are interested in, you’ll likely need some financing to get going. A few brands offer franchise financing in-house, but the majority of franchisees need an outside source of financing. An SBA loan is one of the most popular financing options for franchises, and are available from both local and national lenders.

Bottom Line

SBA loans are one of the most popular franchise financing options, which is why it’s beneficial to use this data to analyze the best and worst franchises. From 2000 to 2018, banks provided over $24 billion in SBA-backed funding to franchises. SBA loan default rates are useful in evaluating a franchise. If a franchise defaulted on an SBA loan, it means it went out of business or didn’t generate enough profits to pay back the loan. Franchises with high success rates not only paid back their loans, but were in business for multiple years.

Many factors go into a franchisee’s ability to repay an SBA loan. That a franchisee has defaulted on SBA loan does not necessarily mean the franchise is unsound or a bad investment. Rather, SBA loan default data should be one of the many considerations informing your decision to invest in a franchise.

If you’re a new franchisee looking for the right business to purchase, it’s important to consider factors other than just SBA default rates. Guidant will make sure you get the full picture before investing. For $495, you can get an estimated business valuation, a financing assessment, an in-depth industry report, and a dedicated valuation specialist to make sure you pay the right price for your franchise of choice.

Visit Guidant