Paying Your Employees: What Options Do You Have?
Charlette has over 10 years of experience in accounting and finance and 2 years of partnering with HR leaders on freelance projects. She uses this extensive experience to answer your questions about payroll.
Heather is a staff writer and payroll specialist with several years of experience working directly with small business owners. Her expertise allows her to deliver the best answers to your questions about payroll.
This article is part of a larger series on How to Do Payroll.
Employers have options when it comes to compensating their workers. In addition to the most common payment methods (direct deposit, pay cards, paper checks, and cash), there are some more creative options to choose from such as stock compensation.
In some states, you have to offer a minimum of two different ways to pay employees or you can be fined. Each payment option has pros and cons and must be managed differently. Be sure that you follow best practices for the payment types you choose.
Tip: Keep in mind that all payment options are not permitted in all states. Before choosing the payment options you want to offer to your employees, make sure to check with your specific states laws and regulations.
1. Direct Deposit
Direct Deposit is the most common way to pay employees, with over 93% of US workers electing to be paid this way. Direct deposit is also one of the easiest ways to pay employees if you’re using payroll software. Payroll processing is all electronic—the money moves from your bank account to your employees’—and you don’t have to do anything but review and approve it. And, as a bonus, it is usually a service that’s included at no additional cost. Some providers, like Gusto, even offer on-demand pay, meaning you can deposit part of an employee’s paycheck that they’ve earned early if they need funds before payday.
If you’re not using payroll software, you can still reap the benefits of direct deposit. You’ll just need to go through your bank to set it up. There is usually a monthly and per-check fee associated with making these direct payments, but some banks, like Wells Fargo, won’t charge you the check fee if the employee has a bank account there. Monthly fees can range from $10 to $30 or more, and check fees are usually between $0.50 to $3.00 each.
Some banks, like Bank of America and SunTrust Bank, are now selling full payroll services. Be sure to inquire about the payroll provider they are using so you can do your own research beforehand. They tend to use popular services like QuickBooks Payroll that you can sign up for on your own.
Tip: If you choose to use your bank’s online payroll processing option, confirm that you’re not paying extra for the same services you can get by signing up with a payroll provider directly.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Direct Deposit
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Doesn’t raise red flags due to an easy paper trail and reporting | Can take days to process depending on your provider |
| Safe | Can cost more than cash/check |
| Convenient for employees | Won’t work for employees without bank accounts |
If you’re interested in learning more about paying your employees by direct deposit, check out our guide.
2. Pay Card
Pay cards are a newer way employers are sending paychecks to employees. They are prepaid debit cards you can use to deposit payroll. It’s a great option to use when you have employees without bank accounts. It allows you and your workers to still reap the benefits of direct deposit while eliminating some of the cons.
Some payroll software offer payroll cards for little to nothing in cost, aside from the expense of the service itself. You can also check with your bank as many of them offer pay cards as well, and the money is FDIC insured.
Many states won’t allow employers to have pay cards be the only way for employees to receive paychecks. Be sure to check your state rules before you decide how to proceed or you could face penalties and/or litigation. Regardless, we recommend using a combination of different ways to pay employees.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Pay Cards
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Completely electronic | Employees can lose access to funds if card is lost/stolen |
| Money is FDIC insured | Some services (ATM withdrawals) can lead to hefty fees for employees |
| Employees don’t need bank accounts | Heavily regulated in some states |
If you’re interested in learning more about paying your employees with pay cards, check out our guide. For help choosing the best service, check out our guide to the best pay card providers for small businesses.
3. Paper Check
Paper checks may seem outdated to some employers, but it is still a reliable way to pay employees for their work. It’s pretty simple, depending on how you’re processing the check. You can print them using your payroll software or handwrite them yourself. Handwriting them is cheaper—unless you print checks online for free—but more time consuming, especially as your business grows.
If you choose to print your paychecks, it’s a good idea to ask your bank about its positive pay options. Positive pay is an automated fraud prevention feature some banks offer that matches the information on checks that are cashed (account number, amount, check number) with a list of checks you have uploaded to its system and authorized for payment. If someone attempts to cash a check from your company that you have not authorized, the bank will reject it.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Paper Checks
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Leaves a paper trail | Can raise red flags with the IRS, no paper trail or reporting |
| Cheaper than electronic options | May be lost or stolen |
| Simplifies payroll for unbanked employees | Have to track when or if each check clears the bank |
If you’re interested in learning more about paying your employee using checks, head over to our guide.
4. Cash
Most businesses distributing paychecks in cash are small and have a handful of employees. And usually, those employees are hourly or part-time workers. Paying thousands in cash every pay period isn’t efficient, so it’s best that you check how much in total you’ll need to pay out each payday before choosing this route.
We don’t usually recommend employers pay their employees in cash due to an increase of being flagged for an audit by the IRS, but it is an option if you’re diligent about creating an audit trail. It’s important that you learn how to do payroll (taxes and all), maintain records of any payroll related debits from your bank account, and create pay stubs for both your employee and your business. Tracking your payroll using excel or even utilizing payroll templates can be a good way to stay organized.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees in Cash
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Quick | Can raise red flags with the IRS |
| Cheap (no processing fees) | More manual work to ensure compliance with payroll laws |
| Flexible (can make emergency payments at the drop of a hat) | Doesn’t work well for all company sizes |
If you’re interested in learning more about how to legally pay your employee using cash, head over to our guide.
5. Stock Compensation
Paying employees in stock isn’t as common as the other ways we’ve discussed, but some employers do use it. We don’t recommend using it to pay the full paycheck amount, unless you have some sort of special arrangement and the stock has value.
Typically, it’s offered as a benefit to make the company more attractive to job candidates vs a replacement for their paycheck. Stock, especially for less established businesses, isn’t usually worth much in the beginning, so future payouts aren’t guaranteed.
One important thing to keep in mind is that you will owe payroll taxes on the stock payment just as you do for regular payroll. The only difference is that it won’t be until the stock actually vests, which means the employee has to remain with the company for a certain period of time before the stock transfer is truly theirs. Five years is a common period that many employers wait before allowing employee stock to fully vest, but there’s usually a partial vesting period around the third year.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Stock
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Can be used to supplement wages that aren’t competitive | It’s a gamble for the employee if the stock doesn’t do well |
| Lets you compensate employees while saving your most liquid asset | Needs to be managed closely to ensure you don’t give up control of the business |
| Can delay payroll taxes | Not an option for companies that aren’t incorporated |
Other Ways to Add Money Back Into Employee Paychecks
These last two ways won’t ever be a substitute for paying employees. In fact, many classify health insurance and discounts as employee benefits. Regardless, they are just a couple of the ways you can add money back into your employees’ paychecks.
Health Premium Contributions
Contributing toward employee health insurance plans can save employees tons of money. Any funds you contribute is akin to increasing their take-home pay, especially for those who would purchase health insurance anyway. Premiums can be expensive, some exceeding $1,000 a month, so review your budget to determine how much you can afford to pay for each employee.
You don’t have to pay the full premium amount. If you have 50 or more employees, we recommend you familiarize yourself with the Affordable Care Act. You may be getting close to being required to provide insurance for your employees; you should definitely ensure you make the minimum contribution amount that the government requires for the plans to be affordable.
A plan is considered affordable if the employee’s required contribution for the lowest cost self-only health insurance option doesn’t exceed 9.5% of their wages. If it does, you’ll need to increase the amount of your contribution to comply.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Health Premium Contributions
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Can be used to supplement wages that aren’t competitive | Insurance costs can rise, so your contribution may need to rise to maintain the same impact |
| Lets you compensate employees while saving your most liquid asset | Young employees who aren’t interested in health insurance may not value it |
| Big motivator for employees returning to the workforce solely for afordable health insurance | Employees may not see the value if they don’t like the plans available to them |
Discounts
There are a couple of ways you can pay employees with discounts: employee discounts on products and services you sell and corporate discounts on products and services from other businesses. Employees can use these at their discretion and really capitalize on the savings if the discounts apply to purchases they already normally make.
Pros and Cons of Paying Employees With Discounts
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| Under an employee discount program, you don’t have to pay for each discount out of pocket | Discounts on your own goods require a quality tracking system |
| Encourages employees to purchase from your company | Company discounts are subject to abuse |
| Supports employees well-being outside of work | Getting access to employee discount programs can cost extra money |
Bottom Line
When it comes to paying your employees or contractors, you should choose payment methods that are best for your business and team. Some ways may seem easier on the surface, like paying your staff with cash, but cause you a headache later.
Remember, you’re responsible for withholding payroll taxes from each paycheck and tracking all earnings so you can pay your portion of employment taxes. It’s also important to make sure that you are mindful of your specific employees’ needs. Do they have bank accounts? What’s most important to them—convenience, discounts, or cash? Whatever you decide, be sure to implement a solid system to track it.
