How To Do Payroll Yourself in 8 Steps (+ Free Checklist)

When people think of payroll, they immediately jump to number crunching. Although calculations are a part of it, you’ll need to understand the overall process to learn how to do payroll. Doing payroll includes everything from setting up your business as an employer to paying your employees, tax agencies, and other applicable entities.

While small business owners tend to be well-versed in the product or service they offer, not everyone has the knowledge or time to tackle all payroll operations. For those small business owners, we recommend trying Gusto. Gusto is an all-in-one payroll service that does things like calculate payroll taxes, pay employees via direct deposit at no additional cost, and more. Click below to start a 30-day free trial.

Visit Gusto

To do payroll the right way with or without software, follow these eight steps:

Step 1. Set Your Business up as an Employer

Assuming you’ve already established your business and applied for any required licenses, the first step to doing payroll is ensuring your business has met all of the legal requirements to operate as an employer. Consider any industry-specific payroll rules you may have to follow as well.

• Apply for a federal employment ID number (EIN)
• Verify your state tax identification number is the same as your federal; if not, determine whether you need to apply for one or if it’s automatically assigned
• Sign up for an account with the Electronic Federal Transfer System
• Start a bank account solely for payroll transactions (separate from your main business account)
• Sign up for any applicable state electronic tax payment accounts
• Purchase workers’ comp insurance; most states require it

Step 2. Establish Your Payroll Process

Now, you will need to make some decisions that will impact how you run payroll each period. You’ll need to invest time in determining what will work for your business. Explore the “why” behind each area. Then, consider the needs of both your employees and your business in addition to any legal requirements for payroll.

• Pay schedule: Will you pay weekly, biweekly, or semimonthly?
• Types of employees (not contractors) you’ll have: full-time vs part-time? Exempt vs nonexempt?
• Tracking work time: Will you need to track work hours? If so, how will you do it, and when will they need to be reported to you?
• Benefits: Will you be offering benefits? Who will pay for them? If employees are paying for them partially or in full, how will you manage the payroll deductions?
• Taxes: How often will you need to pay taxes, and which ones are you subject to? Will you need to pay state taxes? Local? Find out the rates in advance, so you know how much to withhold.
• Payroll processing and calculations: Will you calculate and process payroll using Excel, by hand, with a calculator, or a payroll service?
• Paychecks: Will you be cutting checks and paying via direct deposit? Pay cards? Cash?

Step 3. Collect Your Employees’ Payroll Forms When Hired

Once your employee is ready to start work, you need to collect some important payroll documents. These include tax and work authorization forms, which the employees need to sign.

You’ll use the data on the forms described below to add the employee to your HR or payroll system if you have one. It’s a good idea to store this information in a paper or electronic personnel file.

Federal W-4

A W-4 is the federal tax withholding document that tells you what tax rate to use for the employee. Collect a signed Federal W-4 form for tax withholding. You don’t need to submit this to the IRS, but you should store it in a paper file or electronically in a personnel file.

State W-4 (or equivalent)

The state tax withholding document is similar to the federal and may be called by a different name in your state. Collect a signed State W-4 form for tax withholding and store it in a paper personnel file or electronically.

I-9 Form

Collect a signed I-9 Form for work eligibility verification (within three days of the employee’s start date). You’ll want to make sure the employee can verify their identity and eligibility to work in the United States with a passport or two forms of identification.

Other Payroll Forms

Get direct deposit information from employees via a voided check (if applicable).

Also, you’ll need to register your employee in your state’s New Hire Reporting Program (within 20 days). Make sure that you report all new or rehired employees to your state. Payroll software programs like Gusto often file these reports automatically. The final three steps will be a part of your regular payroll process, unlike the prior three that you only need to do once.

Step 4. Collect Timesheets, Review & Approve

Now you’re ready to start collecting data on your employees’ work time to help determine how much you need to pay them. You’ll need to find total hours worked for the period if you’re paying hourly employees. Salaried employees typically receive the same pay each period, but you can still track their work hours for visibility if needed.

Calculating hours worked is as simple as having the employee write down their start and end times each day and counting up the hours. Lunch breaks are not counted in the total.

Most businesses start out with a simple timesheet. As they grow, they often move up to a time and attendance system or time clock to manage employee schedules, break time, and hours worked.

Here’s an example of an electronic timesheet app from our recommended free timekeeping vendor, Homebase.

Homebase timesheet app

Step 5. Do Payroll Calculations

Once you know how much an employee has worked for the pay period, you can start figuring the important payroll calculations. That includes gross pay, taxes due, deductions for insurance premiums and other benefits, and final net pay.

Gross Pay

Calculating gross pay is as simple as adding up the straight time hours (up to 40 hours within a week) and multiplying by the employee’s hourly rate. Then, add up the overtime hours worked in the pay period and apply the employees’ overtime pay rate to those hours. Straight time is paid at the employee’s regular pay rate, while overtime is calculated at 1.5 times the regular rate of pay.

Payroll Deductions and Taxes

Doing payroll requires you to know in advance what payroll deductions you’re going to make. Deductions include federal and state payroll taxes (be sure you know the tax rates), benefits you might offer, and things like unemployment insurance or Social Security.

Here’s a list of potential deductions with links to more information such as determining what to deduct for each employee. If you use payroll software like Gusto, deductions are processed automatically.

Examples are:

• Social Security and Medicare (FICA)
• Federal unemployment tax (FUTA)
• Deductions based on benefits you offer employees, like health insurance
• Tax deductions based on employee tips
• Miscellaneous deductions such as a uniform expense

To process those deductions, add up all the deductions for each employee to get a total, then subtract that total from the employee’s gross pay. Alternately, you can list each deduction as a line item and subtract them one by one from the employee’s gross pay until you come up with a net pay amount.

Step 6. Pay Employees, Tax Agencies, Benefit Providers

Once you subtract deductions from gross pay, you’ll know the net pay amount you need to pay each employee, including totals for employment taxes and benefits you need to pay out. Be sure to follow the pay schedule you initially set, so employees always know what to expect (if you committed to paying wages every Friday, give yourself enough time in advance to process).

Taxes and benefit providers have their own due dates. Many employers are required to pay these expenses on a monthly basis, but it can vary. You’ll need to pay out the amounts you withheld from your employees’ paychecks in addition to any employer payroll tax and premium amounts your business owes.

Always check before making any payments to determine whether you have enough funds in your payroll bank account. Spending more money than you have can result in unnecessary fees and litigation.

Step 7. Document & Store Your Payroll Records

To remain compliant with federal labor laws, you’ll need to document specific data for each pay period. Retain payroll documents like timecards, pay stubs, and any information regarding pay increases.

If you’re using software like Gusto, the documents are already online or can be uploaded and attached to the employee record. If you’re maintaining documents manually, you’ll want to ensure they’re stored securely.

Step 8. Do Year-End Payroll Tax Reports

As the end of the year draws near, you’ll need to prepare to distribute year-end payroll tax reports. Employees must receive their W-2 forms by Jan. 31 of the following year, and the forms must show their total earnings and taxes paid. If you’re paying independent contractors, you’ll need to prepare 1099 forms instead; this will show earnings but no taxes.

Free Small Business Payroll Checklist

Here’s a checklist you can download to make sure you don’t miss any steps. This checklist will also be helpful if you use payroll software to do payroll.

Download checklist as DOC or PDF

How To Do Payroll With Excel

Businesses that aren’t ready for paid payroll software can save time and money doing payroll with Excel. You can get started with our free template, and all you’ll need to do is add your business’ and employees’ information. With the right formulas in place, tax and check payment calculations are done automatically.

How To Do Payroll With Software

The steps for doing payroll with software are very similar to doing it without; it’s just much easier and faster. You’ll enter all the information for your company and employees electronically, and the paycheck amount and deductions calculate automatically. Most payroll software will even allow you and your employees to complete payroll forms completely online—some will even submit them to the IRS for you.

Find out how easy it is to do payroll with some our recommended software by choosing a provider below:

Select an ArticleHow to do Payroll with QuickBooksHow to do Payroll with GustoHow to do Payroll with PatriotHow to do Payroll with OnPay

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About How To Do Payroll

Payroll is full of so many complex rules and regulations that we realize you may have additional questions. Below we answered some of the most common questions small business owners have about doing payroll.

What Are the Risks of Doing Payroll Without Software?

The biggest risk to your business is that you’ll make a mistake. Without a system to guide you, you may forget to pay taxes, collect deductions, or apply the correct overtime rate, for example.

What Are the Most Common Mistakes Made When Doing Payroll?

• Classifying workers improperly
• Improperly classifying exempt workers
• Miscalculating overtime wages
• Paying the wrong tax rates
• Running payroll late
  (Source: Common Payroll Mistakes by Patriot Software)

What Happens if I Make a Mistake Doing Payroll?

The good news is that if you make a mistake in good faith, you can notify the IRS and your employees (if it affects them) promptly to avoid lawsuits or hefty fees. You’ll need to pay any additional taxes you owe before their due date though.

The most common mistakes are misclassifying employees and paying the wrong wages or taxes, according to software provider Patriot. To avoid these mistakes, we recommend you understand the difference between employees (W2) and contractors (1099), as well as exempt vs nonexempt staff employee, and fix the mistake with no ramifications by providing retro pay.

However, that doesn’t allow you to willingly violate labor practices such as minimum wage, overtime, or sick time pay. Those kinds of mistakes can cost big fines if you’re audited. Educate yourself on labor laws and workplace requirements in your state and location to avoid as many mistakes as possible.

Bottom Line

Learning how to do payroll can be a pain. You have to make sure your business is registered with all the right agencies, fill out forms for each employee, and often purchase workers’ compensation coverage—all on a tight deadline (less than 20 days for most states by law!). Even a seasoned business owner can get overwhelmed when they want to learn how to do payroll. That is why simple software solutions are the easiest and most time-saving options for business owners overall.