Payanywhere vs Square: Which Payments Solution Is Best?
Meaghan has provided content and guidance for indie retailers as the editor for a number of retail publications and a speaker at trade shows. She is Fit Small Business’s authority on retail and ecommerce.
This article is part of a larger series on Payments.
When comparing Payanywhere vs Square, they may appear interchangeable because they both offer a free card reader and an app with point-of-sale (POS) tools. Plus, the credit card processing fees are similar: Payanywhere charges 2.69% per transaction; Square, 2.6% + 10 cents per transaction.
However, Square gets better reviews, offers better software, and generally provides a better value than Payanywhere, although small sellers with average sales below $20 will pay less in transaction fees by choosing Payanywhere.
- Payanywhere: Affordable option for small sellers consistently processing under $5,000 monthly with an average transaction value lower than $20.
- Square: Best for most small businesses, individuals, seasonal or occasional sellers, and those wanting free online and in-store POS systems.
Payanywhere vs Square Quick Comparison
 |  | |
Best for | Small-volume sellers wanting low processing fees | New or small businesses, brick-and-mortar shops, and businesses on a budget |
Monthly fee | $0 | $0 |
Processing fee | 2.69% to 3.49% + 19 cents per transaction | 2.6% + 10 cents to 3.5% + 15 cents per transaction |
Invoice fee | 3.49% + 19 cents | 2.9% + 30 cents, 3.5% + 15 cents if processed using card on file, or 1% for ACH bank transfers |
Average payout | Free next-day funding; same-day funding for 1% | Free 1–2 day funding; instant funding for 1.5% |
Inactivity fee | $3.99/month after 12 months of inactivity | $0 |
Online payments | Virtual terminal, payment links, add to your native app | Square Online store, payment links, add checkout to an existing site, Facebook, Instagram, virtual terminal |
POS features | Basic phone app is free; to use on POS hardware costs $39.95/month | Basic POS is free; advanced available starting at $60/month |
Integrations | Few | Multiple apps in 16 categories |
Ease of use | Good | Excellent |
Customer service | Phone support, chat, email, social media, resource library | Monday–Friday phone support, 24/7 automated chat support, seller community, and resource library |
When to Use a Traditional Merchant Account
A brick-and-mortar store owner might want to consider opening an account with a merchant services provider instead of Square or Payanywhere to save on processing fees. Helcim, for example, offers some of the cheapest credit card processing rates for small businesses.
While using a payments app like Square or Payanywhere is easy and convenient, a traditional merchant account offered through a bank, such as Chase Payment Solutions, offers more security and stability and faster deposit times. Merchant accounts have a longer sign-up process, often charge fees, and may only work with businesses that make a minimum amount of monthly transactions—usually over $5,000.
Why Square Is Best for Most Businesses
Square tops our list of the best merchant services, best mobile credit card processors, and best point-of-sale systems for small businesses. It offers the best all-purpose payment and software solution for individuals, new businesses, and small businesses. In addition, it has advanced paid plans and tools for midsize businesses, from banking services to payroll, and offers custom solutions for large businesses—including reduced rates for high-volume sales. Thus, it can grow with you.
It is free and effortless to use and requires no application or commitment. See our guide to Square to learn more about its different product offerings to see if it’s right for your business.
See why Square tops so many of our evaluations:
Best for Affordability: Square
| | |
Monthly POS subscription | $0–$39.95 | $0–$299 with add-on programs |
Card reader pricing | $0–$49.95 | $0–$49 |
Terminal and register pricing | $549.95–$949.95 + setup fees and POS software subscription | $299–$799 (all-inclusive) |
Card-present transaction fees | 2.69% | 2.6% + 10 cents |
Ecommerce transaction fees | 3.49% + 19 cents | 2.9% + 30 cents |
ACH transaction fees | 3.49% + 19 cents | 1% processing fee, minimum $1* |
Chargeback fees | $25 | $0 |
*ACH payments available only through Square Invoices
Learn more about Square’s costs in our detailed guide to Square fees and pricing.
The processing fees are similar, but if you need more hardware than a simple card reader, Square is by far the cheaper option. Its terminals are well-regarded by users and come with the software free. Payanywhere charges a subscription fee for software on its devices and has a $3.99 per month inactivity fee (after 12 months) if you stop using the app without canceling your subscription.
When Payanywhere Might Be More Affordable
Payanywhere’s 2.69% processing fee seems higher than Square’s 2.6% + 10-cent transaction fee. And for most businesses, it is. However, for sellers with average sales below $20, such as cafes selling cups of coffee, Square’s fee per transaction would be higher than Payanywhere’s additional 0.09% charge per transaction. So, for merchants with low price points, Payanywhere could be more economical.
Best for Payment Processing: Square
| | |
Best for | Low-volume sellers with average sales under $20 | Most individuals and small businesses |
High-volume discounts | Moves you to its merchant account, which is a different contract | Offers discounted rates |
Payment types | Credit card, debit card, contactless payments | Credit card, debit card, contactless payments, gift cards, ACH |
Invoicing | Simple, recurring, autopay | Simple, recurring, autopay |
Virtual terminal | Included | Included |
Card on file | Included | Included |
PCI Compliance | Included | Included |
Our scores for Payanywhere and Square in other articles make Square a clear winner. Both Square and Payanywhere offer flat-rate and transparent pricing for new and small merchants. Once your business starts to grow, Payanywhere will switch you over to a traditional merchant account that uses a tiered pricing model. Generally, we don’t recommend tiered pricing models for small businesses because they can be unpredictable. Learn more about Payanywhere’s pricing and plan options in our Payanywhere review.
Square, on the other hand, does not offer tiered pricing. However, it offers custom discounted rates for businesses processing over $250,000 annually. If your business does process this much, it’s likely neither Square nor Payanywhere is your best option. See our list of the best merchant services for small businesses to see which solution is right for you.
Best POS App: Square
| | |
Best for | Small and midsize businesses, especially those with low-price transactions | Startups, seasonal businesses, solopreneurs, budget-minded small businesses; custom solutions for large businesses |
Industry-specific software options | One all-purpose POS with two themes” “terminal” and “retail” | All-purpose, retail, restaurants, and appointments, CBD retail |
POS features | Basic register, inventory, customer management, employee management. Free for phone; monthly subscription if you use hardware | Free basic register, inventory, customer management, employee management. Plus plans include advanced features, and add-on programs add more functions |
Checkout features | Split tender, open tabs, discounts, tips, digital receipts, refunds | Split tender, open tabs, discounts, tips, digital receipts, refunds, chargeback protection; simplified checkout for consumers with Cash App |
Product catalog | Items, categories, modifiers, discounts, low stock alerts, barcode scanning, phone barcode scanning, reports | Variations, photos, inventory tracking, low-stock alerts, reports, barcode scanning |
Customer management | Customer information and purchase tracking | Customer information and purchase tracking, loyalty features, marketing |
Employee management | Time clock, scheduling, labor forecasts, employee roles with permissions, track sales by employee | Time clock, permissioning, can add on Square Payroll and Team Management |
Integrations | QuickBooks, Homebase, need API for others | Hundreds of apps in 16 categories |
Square is the clear winner when it comes to sales features and functionality. While Payanywhere provides the basics for in-person and online transactions, Square offers many more online sales and customer management features.
Square offers some of the best POS systems for small businesses. (Source: Square)
Square is a recognized leader in sales for both in-store and online. Its free POS system is powerful enough for busy retailers and restaurants but simple enough for the hobbyist who only sells a few items at the farmers market. In 2019, it opened its services to CBD businesses. It offers more features than Payanywhere for customer support, and the paid plans have even greater functionality.
To see all of Square’s app features, read our Square POS review.
New Square Feature: Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)
As of Jan. 31, 2022, Square Online sellers can now offer BNPL payments through Square’s integration with Afterpay, which was recently acquired by Block, Inc. (Square’s parent company).
When to Use Payanywhere
One handy feature Payanywhere offers that Square does not is mobile barcode scanning. Scan the barcode with your phone, and it can pull up the product. This barcode scanner can save you money in equipment and make it easier for employees on the floor to look up items for a customer.
Otherwise, Payanywhere is good when it comes to brick-and-mortar or mobile sales—but not to the level of Square. It does not offer a loyalty program, and most extra functions like marketing will require third-party integrations. Further, its online offerings are weak, consisting of only payment links and a virtual terminal.
Best for Ease of Use: Square
| | |
Apple App Store Rating | ||
Google Play Store Rating | ||
Phone and email support | 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Eastern time, Monday through Friday; 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern time, Saturday and Sunday | 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific time, Monday through Friday |
Online resources | Knowledge base with guides and video tutorials | Knowledge base with guides, videos, articles, and a seller community forum |
Setting up and using Payanywhere and Square are equally easy, but when you get to the reliability of each payment processor, you can break that tie and give the win to Square. Just comparing how intuitive each app is designed, Square pulls ahead.
Square Is a Household Name for a Reason
Square became a household name because it brought payment processing to the small sellers without access to a merchant account—and it made it ridiculously easy to accept credit card payments. The app has easy-to-learn menus and categories, and the language used makes sense.
The user experience is an essential part of an intuitive interface, and Square gets it right with its POS app. You can create new items for your inventory, apply a discount to sales, and set up sales tax without having any prior experience.
Square gets points for designing an app that’s not only user-friendly but also stable. I’ve never had it freeze or crash, and payments always go through.
Payanywhere Is Easy to Set Up but Can Be Unreliable
Getting started with Payanywhere is easy enough. If you choose the Pay As You Go plan, you’ll simply choose the reader you want, fill out a form with your contact information, and then you can sign in and start setting up your profile and inventory. The Payanywhere app is easy to use, and it includes a Test Drive feature, which allows you to try it out before you commit.
As it applies to apps and payment processing software, intuition is such a subjective thing. But when comparing Payanywhere to Square, it doesn’t quite hit the intuitive mark. You can switch between a typical terminal view and retail view, and it isn’t immediately obvious where to go to find inventory (Payanywhere labeled this setting “Themes”).
Despite how easy Payanywhere makes it to start accepting credit cards for payment, it has some issues. The app often freezes, won’t load photos, and crashes—and you have to kill the app then restart it to use it again. These are the sorts of glitches you don’t need when you’re trying to accept someone’s credit card, and you could quickly lose a customer’s trust.
Best Hardware: Square
Square and Payanywhere boast similar hardware offerings, with two card readers for the phone, a handheld mobile terminal, and a standalone terminal. Prices are also similar, with both offering a free mobile card reader when you first sign up. But when you purchase a Payanywhere terminal, you’ll also need to pay a software fee.
When to Choose Payanywhere
Payanywhere offers a broader range of mobile card readers, including an ergonomic terminal that is easier to carry than the Square Terminal. Payanywhere’s free mobile card reader handles swipe and chip payments, whereas Square’s is swipe-only.
Square Reader for Magstripe | Square Reader for Contactless and Chip | Square Terminal |
|---|---|---|
 |  |  |
First free, additional $10 | $49 | $299 or $27 per month for 12 months |
Available with lightning or audio jack input; accepts payments via magstripe (swiped) | Connects via Bluetooth; accepts payments via EMV (chip) or NFC (Apple Pay, Google Pay) | All-in-one credit card machine with POS, card reader, and receipt printer |
Square Register | Commercial Tablet with Stand Kit |
|---|---|
 |  |
$799 (or $39/month) | $649–$1,343 |
Fully integrated POS system with a detachable customer display; accepts chip cards and contactless payments | Square can be run on iPads or Android tablets using the online application; stands work with 10.2” and 10.5” tablets |
2-in-1 Bluetooth Credit Card Reader | 3-in-1 Bluetooth Credit Card Reader | Payanywhere Smart Keypad (Several models available) |
|---|---|---|
 |  |  |
First free, additional $29.95 | $49.95 | $249.95–$449.95 + $9.95–$19.95/month software fee |
Accepts payments swipe and chip payments | Connects via Bluetooth; accepts payments via EMV (chip) or NFC (Apple Pay, Google Pay) | All-in-one credit card reader with POS |
Payanywhere Smart Terminal Mini | Payanywhere Smart Flex | Payanywhere Smart POS+ |
|---|---|---|
 |  |  |
$249 + $9.95/month software fee | $549.95 + $49.95 setup fee and $19.95/month software fee | $949.99 + $99.95 setup fee and $39.95/month software fee |
Complete handheld terminal with POS and card reader | All-in-one credit card machine with POS, card reader, and receipt printer | Fully integrated POS system with attached customer display, card reader, and printer; accepts chip cards and contactless payments; Android only |
Bottom Line
In the battle of Payanywhere vs Square, you could go either way because the two payment processors are so similar and competitive. The free basic POS apps from both companies are easy to use and close to equal in their offerings. Square, however, offers more in terms of functionality, stability, and ease of use.
It is an excellent payment processor and free POS system for any individual or small business owner. It includes support for ecommerce sellers and mobile and storefront sellers. You can get started accepting payment as soon as you create an account with Square. Sign up for free today.
You May Also Like …
- Learn how to process credit cards using Square
- Read our guide to merchant accounts to learn how they work
- Both Payanywhere and Square are two of our top picks for the
