BigCommerce vs Shopify: Which Is Best in 2022?
Meaghan has provided content and guidance for indie retailers as the editor for a number of retail publications and a speaker at trade shows. She is Fit Small Business’s authority on retail and ecommerce.
Agatha Aviso is a writer of the Retail Section at Fit Small Business, focusing on retail software and ecommerce platforms.
This article is part of a larger series on Retail Management.
The choice of the right ecommerce solution for your small business is likely going to come down to BigCommerce vs Shopify. We compared the two platforms based on price, ease of use, third-party app integration, and sales, payment, and management tools.
Closely matched, they tied in several categories (customer support, security, and sales tools). Shopify had the edge in affordability, payment processing, ease of use, and marketing, with BigCommerce having the best product and order management tools. BigCommerce also has no transaction fees.
Based on our BigCommerce vs Shopify evaluation, we recommend:
- Best for small businesses or startups: Shopify
- Best for enterprise-level or high-revenue businesses: BigCommerce
Shopify balances simplicity and ease of use by having all the features small businesses need. This—along with sophisticated point-of-sale (POS) apps, an extensive app marketplace, and plans that can grow with your business—make Shopify the best ecommerce platform for most small businesses.
Meanwhile, BigCommerce allows you to shop around for the lowest transaction fees from any payment processor. While Shopify has limitations on the number of variants each product can have, BigCommerce does not, making it a better option for growing ecommerce businesses that have complex product assortments or want to save on processing fees.
BigCommerce vs Shopify: Quick Comparison
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
4.42 out of 5 | 4.68 out of 5 | |
Best For | Enterprise-level or high-revenue businesses | Small businesses or startups |
Monthly Fees | Starts at $29.95 | Starts at $29; Shopify Lite plan available ($9) |
Additional Sales Channels | Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Google, Walmart, Amazon, and more | Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Etsy, and more |
Ease of Use | Average | Excellent |
POS App | N/A; can be integrated with POS platforms | Yes; free and paid options |
Marketing Features | Excellent | Excellent |
Product and Order Management | Excellent | Average |
App Marketplace | Average | Excellent |
Customer Support | 24/7 email, live chat, and phone | 24/7 email, live chat, and phone |
Are you still undecided about which ecommerce platform to go with? Take our quiz below for a personalized recommendation. You won’t need to enter personal information or be directed to another page.
What Is the best ecommerce platform for you?
Answer a few questions about your business, and we'll give you a personalized product match.
When to Use Shopify
Shopify
Overall Score: 4.68
OUT OF 5
What We Like
- User-friendly interface
- Scalable platform
- Extensive app marketplace for third-party integrations
What's Missing
- Advanced features like reports, fraud analysis, gift cards, and real-time shipping rates only available on higher-tier plans
- Transaction fees if not using Shopify Payments
- Shipping calculator requires an annual plan
Where Shopify Beats BigCommerce:
- Native POS: Shopify POS
- One-click checkout option: Shop Pay
- Social media product links: Shopify Starter Plan ($5/month)
- Shipping discounts: Shopify Shipping and partner couriers
- Marketing tools: Abandoned cart recovery even on first-level entry plan
- Built-in email marketing tool: Shopify email
- Extensive app marketplace: Shopify App Store
If you are a small business with online sales as a primary profit driver, Shopify is a better choice. Shopify’s interface is beginner-friendly but comes jam-packed with management and sales features—along with thousands of third-party integrations—that allow you to scale your business effectively.
The platform also lets you sell on social media—such as Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok—and offers a POS system that can connect seamlessly with your online store for omnichannel sales like buy online, pick up in-store (BOPIS), and browse in-store, buy online.
When to Use BigCommerce
BigCommerce
Overall Score: 4.42
OUT OF 5
What We Like
- No transaction fees with numerous payment processing integrations
- Ability to sell on enterprise and ecommerce app
- Extensive product options and variants
What's Missing
- Customization tools aren’t beginner-friendly
- Abandoned cart recovery is only available in higher plans
- Lacks native POS tool, which needs third-party integration
Where BigCommerce Beats Shopify:
- Product management: Configure up to 600 product variants and custom work order fields; sell digital products without a third-party app
- Zero transaction fees: No transaction fees for choosing third-party payment providers
- Automatic language and currency detection: Automatic geolocation is turned on even on first-level entry plan
- Real-time shipping calculator: Rates from third-party carriers even on basic tier
- Built-in/native marketplace integrations: Amazon, eBay, and Walmart
We consider BigCommerce a close runner-up to Shopify in being the best overall ecommerce platform. If you are an online store with a complex and extensive product inventory, BigCommerce is a better fit than Shopify. BigCommerce lets you set up 250 product options and up to 600 variants, which is more than other ecommerce platforms usually allow, including Shopify.
We particularly recommend BigCommerce for high-revenue businesses that want to save on transaction fees. It allows you to pick your payment platform with no added transaction fees, unlike Shopify, which charges a fee if you use a third-party processor. BigCommerce also offers exclusive PayPal discounts, connects with more than 65 gateways, and accepts multiple currencies.
Best for Affordability: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
Online Store Plans | $29.95 to $299.95/month | $29 to $299/month |
Starter Plans (Create product links for social media) | N/A | $5/month |
The most outstanding value of Shopify over BigCommerce is the Shopify Lite offering ($9/month), which gives you basic features, such as the Shopify POS app, the ability to accept credit cards, and integration with your existing website. That’s a lot for $9 monthly, and BigCommerce has no answer to it.
BigCommerce and Shopify have three-tiered pricing structures and custom plans for enterprise businesses that are remarkably similar. The lower tiers start with basic tools, such as a branded online store, unlimited product sales, social media integration, and 24/7 support. It’s when you start paying more that you get access to premium tools that include detailed reporting and customer segmentation.
Suppose you were to unpack both platforms’ basic plans, Basic Shopify and BigCommerce Standard. BigCommerce’s Standard provides more robust features, specifically:
- Professional reporting features
- Built-in ratings and review system
- Automatic currency conversion, based on geolocation
- Real-time carrier shipping quotes from third-party carriers
However, Basic Shopify has these advantages:
- No sales limits, compared to a $50,000-per-year sales limit on BigCommerce Standard
- Abandoned cart recovery on its entry-level plan; BigCommerce only offers it starting on its Plus plan at $79.95 per month
Do you want to learn more? Read our comprehensive guide to Shopify pricing.
Best for Payment Processing: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
Built-in Payment Provider (optional) | PayPal powered by Braintree (special discounted rates) | Shopify Payments |
Option to Connect to Third-Party Processor | Yes; no fees or markups | Yes; 0.5% to 2% fee |
Payment Gateway Options | 65-plus | 100-plus |
Financing Options (Buy Now, Pay Later Options) | None, but third-party integration is available | Yes, Shop Pay (built-in) and third-party apps |
POS for In-person Sales | None, but third-party integration is available | Yes, Shopify POS (free and paid plans available) |
Shopify offers built-in payment processing through Shopify Payments and Shop Pay (its one-click checkout solution). This means anyone can start accepting payments from day one without needing to apply for and connect a separate merchant account. This is the easiest option for most small and new businesses, and Shopify’s transaction fees are pretty standard.
When it comes to processing fees, BigCommerce’s most significant advantage over Shopify is it doesn’t charge any transaction fees for connecting a third-party processor. Rather than bundling its payment processor, it gives you the option to pick the payment gateway that’s right for you. So, larger businesses that process many transactions can shop around for the lowest rates.
Arguably the most considerable advantage Shopify has over BigCommerce is its proprietary POS app. The POS app allows you to start taking payments immediately, without the hassle of setting up a third-party solution. Shopify sells several very convenient credit card scanners if you’re selling in person. However, you are not locked into using Shopify’s payment system, and the service is compatible with most of the third-party solutions also offered by BigCommerce.
Built-in Payment Processors
- BigCommerce: PayPal powered by Braintree provides preferential PayPal processing rates and a system where a customer can pay via PayPal without ever having to leave your storefront.
- Shopify: Shopify Payments gives you the ability to set up a local currency on your checkout page and the Shop Pay feature—this is similar to Apple Pay and Google Pay in that shoppers can complete orders in one click.
Best for Ease of Use: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
Onboarding and Setup | Yes; easy-to-follow setup wizard | Yes; easy-to-follow setup wizard |
Store Management | Not as beginner-friendly; too many customization options | Beginner-friendly |
Onboarding & Setup
When we compared BigCommerce vs Shopify, we found they’re both somewhat accessible to the everyday user. However, Shopify has a significant advantage in that nearly anyone who has even minimal computer skills can pick it up almost immediately.
Building an Ecommerce Site With BigCommerce
If you’re new to selling online, BigCommerce could pose something of a challenge. The sheer breadth and scope of what this platform can do can be overwhelming. Nevertheless, there’s nothing you shouldn’t be able to figure out after just a few times through the process.
BigCommerce has a setup wizard you can see from your dashboard when you sign up. It also has links to other sections in the backend that will allow you to set up advanced settings for your store. (Source: BigCommerce)
For a look into the step-by-step process, read our guide on how to set up your BigCommerce store.
Building an Ecommerce Site With Shopify
Shopify is arguably the most user-friendly ecommerce platform out there—it’s WordPress for online retailers. Its entire feature set is accessible from every interface window, and all the tools are learned and used quickly. If you have any trouble with Shopify’s toolset, there’s a wealth of help options that will show you exactly how things are done.
Shopify’s setup wizard is easy to follow with prompts and help bubbles you can click on to take you to detailed step-by-step guides in the Help Center.
(Source: Shopify)
Shopify has an extensive support section for first-time Shopify users, accessible right inside your Shopify dashboard.
(Source: Shopify)
To see what goes into setting up an online store using Shopify, read our guide on how to set up your Shopify store.
Store Management
Both platforms are easy to use and navigate, but since BigCommerce’s features are more scalable, they provide more customizations, which is less suited for beginners.
Adding products to your Shopify store is intuitive. You can set up all the details within your product page—descriptions, images, inventory, shipping, and even SEO. (Source: Shopify)
For example, adding products is straightforward with Shopify. There are also help bubbles in most fields, such as a sales tip about comparing prices.
With BigCommerce, product listings are very customizable. You can see from the images below that you can set up as many details as you want when listing your products for your BigCommerce store.
Best for Design: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
Free Templates | 12 | 9 |
Paid Templates | 100-plus (starting at $150) | 83 (starting at $180) |
Editing Tool | Drag-and-drop builder | Drag-and-drop builder |
Customization | Yes (CSS and HTML) | Yes (CSS and HTML) |
Both Shopify and BigCommerce provide you with tools to create a fully customized online store. BigCommerce might have more templates to offer, but Shopify wins this category for its varied themes and newly upgraded website builder.
Shopify has a user-friendly theme store with free and professional options. (Source: Shopify)
Both Shopify and BigCommerce provide a selection of free and paid themes. Shopify themes offer more variety in design. The most common feedback about BigCommerce themes is that they differ only in color.
When it comes to editing, BigCommerce’s page builder uses a drag-and-drop interface that will enable you to edit and see changes in real time easily.
Big Commerce’s drag-and-drop builder allows you to see changes to your store in real time. (Source: BigCommerce)
Shopify recently upgraded its website builder called Online Store 2.0 (OS 2.0), along with new themes, which offer more customization options than the previous version of the website builder. OS 2.0 introduces sections and blocks that offer modularity, flexibility, and moderate drag-and-drop capabilities.
When we created our demo store with Shopify, we found it easier to build page sections using its building blocks. Real-time changes were also viewable on the right side of the editor.
With the OS 2.0 update in Shopify themes, you can expect a more user-friendly setup with drag-and-drop building blocks. (Source: Shopify)
Best Product & Order Management: BigCommerce
| | |
|---|---|---|
Import/Export Products/Data | CSV and XML | CSV |
Digital Goods | Yes; built-in | Yes; using a third-party app (free and paid version available) |
Product Variants | Up to 600 | Up to 100 |
Product Categories | Manual and Bulk Edit | Manual and Smart/Automatic |
Custom Product or Work Order Tools | Yes | Only with add-on |
Real-Time Tracking in Between Locations/Channels | Yes | Yes, but with an app |
Real-Time Shipping Calculators | Across all plans | Available in highest plan, Advanced Shopify |
Shipping Discounts | No | Yes, with Shopify Shipping (discounts depend on plan) |
Product Management
Importing & Exporting Products or Data
In terms of exporting your data, Shopify allows you to export to comma-separated values (CSV) file format. BigCommerce is more flexible because it allows you to export to CSV and XML.
Product Categories
Setting up collections in Shopify and BigCommerce is straightforward enough, but Shopify’s approach is better because products can be populated automatically based on tags or product descriptions. Although BigCommerce has a “bulk edit” option to assign products into categories, it doesn’t provide the “smart collection” functionality.
You can see a visual comparison of how to set up categories in each platform below:
Product Options
Shopify lets you set up only three options per product, while BigCommerce lets you set up to 250. It can also auto-generate stock keeping units (SKUs) for all the different combinations of variants. Its limit on product variants is up to 600, a far cry from Shopify’s equivalent limit of only 100.
Custom Product or Work Order Tools
If your store products have customization options such as engraving, image uploads, and more, setting this up using custom fields and image uploads is done easily in BigCommerce. Image uploads up to 500MB are accepted. In Shopify, this can only be done using third-party apps.
In BigCommerce, you can set up custom work order tools such as custom messages (text, number, date in single or multiple lines), swatches, and images. (Source: BigCommerce)
Inventory Management
Keeping track of your inventory is a snap with Shopify. The “Products” tab gives you an at-a-glance view of the products you have on hand and how many are coming in, and it allows you to take set actions when inventory runs low manually. Moreover, each item you sell has an easily editable product page where you can input and modify a variety of variants, including descriptions, prices, and shipping.
Shopify has a slight edge over BigCommerce in this area when put side by side. Shopify has smart inventory management tools to automate product categories and a fulfillment network for storing and fulfilling orders. You can even adjust inventory from the mobile app. Plus, a complete setup with Shopify POS gives you full visibility to manage products and orders in an omnichannel setting. It is our top recommendation for multichannel POS systems.
An example of Shopify’s inventory management system: You can set stock inventory levels per product in the product listing pages or go to the inventory tab from your dashboard. It is easier to see at a glance which stocks are running low and add incoming inventory. (Source: Shopify)
Meanwhile, the “Products” tab on BigCommerce’s main interface gives you instant access to your inventory, making it easy to see what is available in your store, add new products, and search your inventory. You can even import your inventory spreadsheet into the interface. You’ll have a sample product inventory to help you learn when you start out—something you don’t get with Shopify.
Shipping Tools
Both BigCommerce and Shopify allow you to set up a variety of shipping rules, such as:
- Free shipping rates
- Flat rates
- Price-based rates
- Weight-based rates
- Calculated (“real-time”) shipping rates from third-party carriers
BigCommerce, however, wins when it comes to providing customers with third-party real-time shipping rates—making it available on all of its plans. With Shopify, you’ll need to be on the $299 Advanced Shopify to unlock this feature.
One thing to note is that Shopify can provide real-time shipping quotes and discounts on any plan if you choose to use Shopify Shipping and its partner couriers.
Best Sales Tools: Tied
| | |
|---|---|---|
Buy Now Button | Yes ($29.95 plan) | Yes ($9 plan) |
One-click Checkout Link | Yes; Bolt integration (starts at $19.99/month) | Yes; Shop Pay (no added fee but must use Shopify Payments) |
Social Media Integration | Yes | Yes |
BigCommerce and Shopify don’t limit your sales to your online storefront. They enable you to sell on popular sales platforms such as Facebook, Amazon, eBay, and Instagram. However, Shopify has industry-leading partnerships with social channels like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. If you want the ability to offer in-app social media sales, Shopify is for you.
BigCommerce also allows you to sell on enterprise and ecommerce apps, including Google Shopping, Walmart Marketplace, and PriceGrabber. These are far more options than you get with Shopify. If these marketplace channels are more important to you than social channels, BigCommerce is your best option.
Learn how to sell on Amazon and Walmart Marketplace.
Best Marketing Features: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
Banners | Yes | Yes, depending on store theme |
Gift Cards, Discount and Coupon Codes | Yes, on all plans | Yes, on all plans |
Customer Reviews | Yes | Yes (but not Google reviews) |
Product Reviews | Yes | Yes, but with an app |
Native Email Marketing | No | Shopify Email |
Abandoned Cart Recovery | Yes, but starts on Plus plan ($79.95/month) | Yes, on all plans (from the $29 tier) |
As powerful ecommerce platforms, both Shopify and BigCommerce know the importance of marketing for online stores, and they provide excellent tools to help get your site noticed.
Abandoned Cart Recovery
One feature worth highlighting is the abandoned cart recovery for marketing. Setting up abandoned cart recovery emails lets you interact with customers who don’t place or finish their orders to lure them back. You can customize your emails and add schedule triggers and discount codes as a way of enticing customers back to your store. You can also customize confirmation emails sent to customers when they order.
Learn more about shopping cart abandonment.
BigCommerce’s abandoned cart saver feature claims to recover up to 15% of lost sales and lets you send up to three automated follow-up emails compared to Shopify’s single email. However, the feature is available across all Shopify plans―starting at the $29 plan―whereas BigCommerce unlocks this feature at the $79.95 tier.
Email Marketing
Another essential part of marketing your online store is sending e-newsletters to your mailing list. This helps generate more sales.
Learn more about how email marketing works.
Shopify has a native email marketing tool, Shopify Email. Everyone on a paid Shopify plan is entitled to send 2,500 free emails each month. You get to customize your email look with templates and schedule their delivery, but advanced email marketing features, such as automation and customer behavior segmentation, are unavailable.
Shopify Email provides templates you can use to send newsletters, announcements, and marketing emails to your customers. (Source: Shopify)
BigCommerce doesn’t have a built-in email marketing tool yet, but free third-party email marketing integration options, such as Mailchimp, are available.
Best App Marketplace: Shopify
| | |
|---|---|---|
App Marketplace | Extensive | Extensive |
Number of Available Integrations | 1,000+ | 7,000+ |
Shopify beats BigCommerce when it comes to available third-party integrations, offering more than 7,000 compared to BigCommerce’s 1,000-plus. If there’s something your store needs, it’s a near certainty that you’ll find it in Shopify’s app store.
Shopify’s app store has thousands of integrations with product suppliers, shipping solutions, affiliate programs, and more. What we like about it are its categories and recommendations. You can find an app that you need easily. (Source: Shopify)
Both Shopify and BigCommerce have organized categories that can be easily searched.
Best for Security: Tied
| | |
|---|---|---|
SSL Certificates | Free and paid ($59 to $299) | Free |
PCI-Compliant | Yes | Yes |
SSL Certificates
Both BigCommerce and Shopify offer free secure sockets layer (SSL) certificates on all of their plans. The only difference between the two platforms is that you cannot install a third-party SSL certificate on Shopify. With BigCommerce, you have the option to upgrade to a more advanced SSL certificate equipped with site seals and warranties. BigCommerce offers GeoTrust security certificates, with prices ranging from $59 to $299.
PCI Compliance
Both BigCommerce and Shopify are also Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)-compliant providers. Both platforms meet the PCI DSS requirements to protect against credit card data breaches.
Best for Customer Support: Tied
| | |
|---|---|---|
Online Knowledgebase | Extensive | Extensive |
Community Forum | Yes; active and helpful community members | Yes; active and helpful community members |
Customer Support: Live Chat, Email, and Phone | 24/7 | 24/7 |
Just as you should provide excellent care to your own customers, Shopify and BigCommerce want to take excellent care of you. If you ever have a problem, both offer 24/7 support through various channels.
BigCommerce’s support page is a simple affair. The first step is seeing if there’s a simple answer to your problem that doesn’t involve another person. If a Help Center article can’t resolve your issue, you have the option to chat with an agent live, send an email, or speak with a representative on the phone. Whenever we interacted with customer support, the agents were informed, courteous, and eager to help resolve small and complicated issues.
What we like about BigCommerce’s Help Center is that you can view shortcuts to its knowledge base, community forum, video tutorials, and more. If you click on the Contact Menu on top, you can see if the platform has system issues (by its status) and reach out to customer agents for assistance. (Source: BigCommerce)
Shopify’s help page is similar to BigCommerce’s in that it tries to resolve your problem with helpful articles and tips before handing you over to support staff. You can reach them directly via live chat, email, and phone. They also reply to support inquiries via Twitter. Like BigCommerce, Shopify’s team is professional, competent, and ready to assist you.
Shopify’s Help Center has different categories: Start, Sell, Manage, Market, and Expand, all of which lead to different articles and guides on how to set up and manage a Shopify store. Its customer support button is also displayed prominently throughout its website. (Source: Shopify)
How We Evaluated BigCommerce vs Shopify
To help you decide which ecommerce platform is best for your store, we compared BigCommerce and Shopify on price, ease of use, store builder and design tools, inventory management, and sales tools. We also added our own expert opinion based on years of experience testing different ecommerce platforms:
15%
Pricing and Payment Processing
30%
Store Builder and Design Features
30%
Inventory and Sales Features
15%
Ease of Use
10%
Expert Score
15% of Overall Score
We considered the price point of each base plan that offers a complete online store, what plan options are available as your business grows, and payment processing options, including fees, flexibility, and one-click checkout options. Shopify edges out BigCommerce in this comparison. While they have similar plan options, Shopify offers a better overall value with a free connected POS app and Shop Pay (its one-click checkout option). BigCommerce, on the other hand, has sales caps on its plan tiers, which can force you into a pricier plan.
30% of Overall Score
We considered how easy it is to build and maintain a professional and attractive online store, including available templates, customization options, free domain and SSL certificates, unlimited storage and bandwidth options, and built-in SEO tools and site analytics. BigCommerce offers a better drag-and-drop site editing tool with more flexibility than Shopify’s “what you see is what you get” (WYSIWYG) editor. However, Shopify offers more variety in its available themes, which is best for new ecommerce sellers.
30% of Overall Score
We looked at what kind of product assortments Shopify and BigCommerce can accommodate; tools for in-store and mobile, integrated social media, and marketplace selling; and marketing tools. We also consolidated shipping options and PCI compliance. Shopify and BigCommerce are tied in this area. In general, they both offer similar features, with a few distinctions.
15% of Overall Score
Because online stores operate 24/7, we prioritized platforms that offer 24/7 customer support and have multiple customer touchpoints, such as phone, email, and chat. Both Shopify and BigCommerce offer 24/7 support, so they are tied. However, Shopify’s platform is more intuitive and easier to navigate, especially if you’re new to ecommerce and site builders.
10% of Overall Score
Here, we considered overall value, quality of features, popularity, customer satisfaction, and ease of use. We also factored in our own experience working with each platform and feedback from businesses who use each system. Shopify beats BigCommerce in our expert review because of its popularity, ease of use, and industry-leading innovations.
*Percentages of overall score
Bottom Line
When choosing between Shopify and BigCommerce, it’s going to come down to what kind of business you have. If you run a large enterprise that requires numerous user accounts, you need BigCommerce. However, Shopify’s easy-to-use nature and Shopify Lite offering make it the clear winner for small businesses, solopreneurs, and budding enterprises.
We recommend Shopify for anyone launching an ecommerce platform for the first (or second and third) online storefront. It’s easy to sell your products as early as the first day of your 14-day free trial, so start yours today.
You May Also Like…
- Follow our guide to starting a retail business
- Learn how to start an online store
- Sell like an ecommerce expert with sales-driving strategies
